Jennifer Aniston and Justin Theroux dined with Howard Stern and others on Friday, and a photo taken that night made its way online and had fans hoping for a rekindled romance.

Jennifer and Justin didn’t appear to be sitting near each other during the big group dinner but they all seemed relaxed as they engaged in conversation. An unidentified woman sat between the exes but it’s unclear if she was Justin’s date or just a friend of the group. “Jen is just STUNNING in real life!” the caption for the photo, which was posted by a social media user, read.

Once the photo made its way to Twitter, users couldn’t help but comment. “Jen and Justin out to dinner together! Either they’re just really good friends or else they still love one another,” one user wrote. “If Jen gets back with Justin that would be the best thing to happen in” another gushed. A third shared, “This woman deserves all the happiness in the world.”

Jennifer and Justin’s latest outing together doesn’t come as too much of a surprise since they are known to still be good friends. They have publicly shared sweet birthday messages to each other on social media since their split and have spoken highly of one another in interviews. Their friendship has also been dubbed one of the best post-breakup friendships in Hollywood.